Pages

Showing posts with label CRITICISM AND ITS RESPONSE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CRITICISM AND ITS RESPONSE. Show all posts

Response to allegation accusation by humbleness and humility and to be silent on hardest comment


Below is the Translation of an Arabic Article by
Fazilatus Shaykh Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi R.A
(Faisal Award winner,Former Vice Chancelor of Darul uloom Nadwatul Ulema Lucknow India,and Former president of All India Muslim Personal Law Board, (AIMPLB) author of above hundred books,One of the greatest Islamic scholar of last century. 

The Religious reflection of Maulana Ilyas
When Hazrat Maulana Muhammad Ilyas (Died 1944 ,1364H) observed decrease in religious sentiments, increase in irreligiousness of society, accelerating influence of western culture and found even some of elites of society under the grip of Materialism, westernize  and inattentive of Dawah.
He observed our Religious personalities and Institution has become small islands between sea of irreligiousness, there general impact on society has decreased , there direct contact with general Public has ended, and the time is very critical.
He Realised and decided not to sit in a corner, and not to be contained with whatever he was already doing for Islam. He decided to make direct contact with general Public.

As the diseased (General Muslims) has not aware of their disease so surely they will not approach the Ulema and scholars. Rather it has to be done from Ulema side.
Thats why Maulana Ilyas stressed most on making direct contact with General Muslims, and to cultivate and nourish Emaan in their heart. To strengthen The Aqeedah of tawheed in them. They should be taught the basics of Deen and necessary Masael (Islamic  rules of daily life). They should be motivated for Islamic knowledge for themselves (and their children).
He also stressed to be very careful for all the Islamic Methodology of Dawah, etiquettes, manners and Rulings so that the Dawah should be effective and to save the movement from trials and tribulations. Foremost among these etiquettes are, Ikram e Muslim giving others priority over oneself (despite one's dire needs)refraining as far as humanly possible from unprofitable and unnecessary preoccupations.
Start of the Movement and its Evolution
Maulana Muhammad Ilyas initiated the movement from most backward region of India, known as Mewat (State of Haryana ) bordering Delhi. This area was very infamous on scale of ignorance to Islam, being unaware from even basic of deen, and almost non practicing on islam.
Maulana Ilyas motivated and invited the people of the area for temporary migration adjusting their temporal engagement, and to go in groups accompanying some knowledgeable people in other areas for learning deen, Islamic nurturing and Dawat o Tabligh. Because Maulana Ilyas was of view that unless and until they will not leave their ignorant and corrupt society in which they are living, they cannot learn or understand deen, Islamic manners and not possible for them to practice the shariah.
Thousands of people from this area accepted the Dawah and actively participated. They sacrificed a lot for weeaks, months and even for year for the sake of Allah in his path. They ore hardship for Islam many a time went on foot in the absence of means of transportation (As they were poor and resource limited people).
They learned deen for themselves, Practiced deen and developed the spirit of deen in them.
Within a short period of time this Dawah movement spreaded all over India. It affected and touched the heart and mind of people across the sections of society.
What was the deriving force behind this speedy success of Dawah? It was not due to
          Any Advertisement in news papers,
          Any collection of money from public or government
          Any pamphlet banner poster or any propaganda means.
The force behind this phenomenal success was
First “Its Dawah methodology was very close to the Dawah and Reformation methods adopted at initial period of Islam.
Second “The Ikhlas and sincerity of intention to please Allah in Dawah worker (People associated with this movement) was giving glimpse of the era of Salafus salehin period (Early generation of Muslims) who sacrificed in the path of Dawah and strived in the path of Allah only with the intention to please the Almighty. They bore all difficulties with patience with smile.
Slowly the effect of the movement spreaded the countries and continent of the world. The movement of Jamaat started in America Europe Africa Australia, its affected people motivating them for reformation, preparation for life after death, and doing effort for reforming others.

The strengthening of Jamaat against the opposers.
(Note: In this section the Fazilatuz sheikh Nadvi being an author and historian expressing the truth has been outspoken and has took names of some groups and persons to describe the sequence of events of opposition of Tablighi Jamaat. But the policy of Maulana Ilyas (closely followed by Markaz Nizamuddin elder is not to involve in these matters in any form. Maulana Inamul Hasan (R.A.)(died 1995) the former Amir of Tableeghi Jamaat has said."It is better that in case the objections and criticism if they are correct, rectify them .{No one is free from shortcomings} Whereas if they are wrong ,have patience (leave the matter to Allah)."
(Book Insight into dawah and its understanding & cognition Page No 181 translation of urdu book Dawat ki Faham o baseerat or uska Idrak) They have no complain to any person/organization. For them 

Although the blogger personal opinion is with sheikh nadvi rahimullah to tell the truth openly and to stop the propaganda and false information spreaded against dawat o tabligh by groups/people of vested interest. so that mslim ummah could be saved from this misinformation and mayget benefitted from blessed work of dawat o tabligh.
But Respecting the Markaz view in the translation those portions has not been translated . Rather this portion has been dotted as..............Ulema who want to know may refer original Arabic article. 

For general Muslims knowing these name is of no use, What is useful to them is to know the lesson on response of Dawah worker to opposers and their patience, faith on Allah,high morale, and to continue work of Dawah in adverse situations.)

In Indian subcontinent (India Pakistan Bangladesh) a fierce Propaganda was started against this movement as it silently started removing the unislamic ideologies thoughts,customs, practices, innovation and rituals prevalent at that time in Muslim Society… The Foremost oppose group against Dawat o  Tabligh     movement…………………….. was………………………… …………………………………………………………….. ………………..………..……………………………………………..…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………..To limit its impact of Dawah they utilised programme of misinformation and all sorts of means. Their basic means was “ To make so much noise, misinformation and propaganda so that the voice of Dawah movement will be suppressed.”

But Allah is the witness that ……
In the face of baseless allegation, wrong accusations, Psychological and mental torture, and many times physical assaults, the Dawah brothers remained intact. What to talk about taking revenge or distracting from the path of Dawah, these events further strengthened their patience,fortitude, positivity, and aspiration of objective and goal.

There meekness, humbleness and humility and to be silent on hardest comment brought so much effect that many of their oppose became became their follower. Thousands of people involved in Innovation and Polythestic practices made Taubah and returned to the Tawheed of Allah and started following the path of Prophet Muhammad sallallahu Alaihi wasallam.
All those onlookers and close observers who have seen the areas of work of Tablighi jamaat can give the eye witness account for all these.

Individual mistakes and shortcomings cannot be attributed to Jamaat
Now if people associated with movement make any mistakes, unknowingly doing some wrong, any punishable action, so these are faults on the part of individuals in understanding its methodology. And its imposition on jamaat is not justifiable or acceptable.
The views of Allama Syed Sulaiman Nadvi Rahimullah on Tablighi Jamaat.
(Shekh abl hasan writes)This article and remark is finished with the words of Syed Sulaiman Nadvi Rahimullah that he has written as last lines in the preface of my book life and mission of Maulana Ilyas Rahimullah.
“This Da'wat Closely Resembles with the Da'wa: of the Holy Prophet sallallahu Alaihi wasallam :
“In the above lines, I've tried to explain some principles of da'wat and tableegh to my readers and I believe that, after studying these they will be able to form a realistic idea of the essence of Islamic da'wat and of the proper mode of presenting this da'wat to the people. I dare to say that, of all the religious movements of the present-day India', (These words were written in 1947,The tableegh movement was largely based in India at that time) the one known as 'Da'wat and Tableegh' bears the closest resemblance both in method as well as in spirit-with the true Islamic da 'wat initiated by the Holy Prophet Muhammad sallallahu Alaihi wasallam.
The Importance of Tableegh: A wisely-planned [system of] da'wat and tableegh, amr bil ma'roof, and nahi a'nil munkar is the backbone of the entire body of Islam. It is da'wat on which depends the foundation, strength, expansion and success of Islam. I believe that, in these days, da'wat is more needed than it was needed in any time in the past; and in contrast with converting the non Muslims to Islamic Faith, this is more important to make Muslims as Muslim, i.e., making effort on those who are Muslims in name or by nationality so that they become true and dutiful Muslims. In the light of the present-day religious state of Muslims, it becomes the duty of every Muslim to raise the cry of the Holy Qur'an:
يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا آمِنُوا
O you who believe, do believe in Allah and His Messenger and in the Book [Q, '4:136]
With all force and potentials.
This demands that we go about from city to city, village to village, and from door to door, persuading those who are Muslims in name to become true Muslims by faith and by practice.
And in this path, that amount of dedicated hardwork, consistent effort, courage and tolerance should be invested which the worldly people are employing for gaining worldly honor and authority. That is, that dedication to the cause which inspires such an insurmountable power in the people that they get willing to sacrifice their most prized possessions even their own lives and pledge to remove any obstruction that might possibly hinder the progress of their mission. To promote the cause of da'wat, we should use all means; invite peoples' attention towards it, utilize honest efforts, and in fact invest all our life and possessions- and try to take a step forward in this field in a way or the other.
And for achieving this objective, we should inspire in our self that restlessness without which neither any work, worldly or spiritual, has ever been completed in past and nor will get completed in future. If you want to see the examples of the men of determination of the field of da'wat in this age, please start reading the actual book (to which this essay is the introduction).
With regards from one who is aware of his humble knowledge."

WAMA ALAINA ILLAL BALAGHUL MUBEEN

Books Article clearing Answering Tablighi jamaat misconception criticism


Books and Articles from Tabligh Answering   Allegations and Criticism.

According to their policy Tabligh elders never indulge in any arguement and counterarguement.

So there is no Book or Reply from Tablighi Jamaat elders is Available.

Whatever articles and writing for clarification of doubts and allegation has been written are from brothers who has written individually.

Although these are not systematic writing but it is sufficient in written form also who want to know truth.


Although the understanding the work of Tabligh can only be in the path of Allah.Through articles they can partially understand the reality of doubts and allegation.

But those who work for Allah, Allah helps them Unexpectedly.


There is general perception that Salafi Brothers remain against Tabligh.
(Although it is not always true I personally know many Salafi brothers actively with the work of Tabligh.)


but it is 
Allah Power and mercy that the only complete book clearing allegation against Tabligh has been written by a Salafi Alim
1. Shaikh Abu Bakar Jabir Al Jazairi

  Who was Teacher at jamea madeena munawwara and at Masjid e Nabwi sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam Madeena Munawwara, who travelled to Europe and Africa and got first hand information of Tabligh work and finally


has written book in Arabic which has been translated in urdu Titled “Tablighi Jamaat ka Belag Jaeza” (“An Unbiased study of Tablighi Jamaat”.published by Al Markazul Arabi Lilkitab,U.A.E.)

This book is available at following link Another article By Sheikh Yusuf Malahi in Arabic All these  Urdu translation is available on this link.




3. http://islamicbookslibrary.wordpress.com/category/tableegh/

4.http://www.tauheed-sunnat.com/sunnat/category/urdu-islamic-books/dawat-o-tableegh


CONCLUSION
In every criticism there is a either a lesson or
reward for Akhirah........................if someone is pointing out your short coming actually he is helping you. Rectify it as told by Maulana Inamul Hasan sb also.
 

If it is baseless allegation. Just do Sabar 


Because if you will do sabr (Patience) on baseless allegation Allah will surely give you Reward. 

Be sure of it . (InshaAllah I will quote the Hadith in this regard Later on Jazakallah)

Lesson Guidance in criticism pondering over mistakes wrong introspection


THERE IS LESSON IN CRITICISM

When you do the work of Dawah encourage others to 

do good, you should remember everyone is not going 

to listen open heartedly.  

Some are going to oppose you also. 


It is for this very reason that in this path one gets to take lesson from the enemy 
(i.e. from the opposition and from those who oppose this effort). 

You will meet ten different people, will make ten different comments.

Someone will say,
Grave Worshiper ‘wahhabi’‘bid’ati’ Mushrik etc..

and Whatever they want..............

They have a tongue and Allah has given liberation in the world So remain ready for many more..................harsh comments will be made.

When listening to all of this, you will start pondering that what is wrong with me?????????????What are my weaknesses?????????????? 

Then you will search for those shortcomings found within you and try to eliminate them. 

Nevertheless, in this path you will attain the suh’bah (companionship) of the pious, you will obtain good friends and you will receive the opportunity to take 

lesson from the enemy.

Tablighi Jamaat leaders Nizamuddin Markaz Response stand views


WHAT  IS  THE     ELDERS     (OF TABLIGH)    STAND   ON      CRITICISM ????????????

The Tablighi Jamaat elders (other call leaders) at Markaz Hazrat Nizamuddin, Delhi,India have a

written policy of not indulging in any argument and counterarguement and defence in the case of criticism and allegation.
Maulana Inamul Hasan (R.A.)(died 1995) the former Amir of Tableeghi Jamaat has said.

"It is better that in case the objections and allegation if they are correct, rectify them . 


Whereas if they are wrong ,have patience (leave the matter to Allah)." 
(Insight into dawah and its understanding & cognition  PAGE NO 181          translation of urdu book Dawat ki Faham o baseerat or uska Idrak) 

MAULANA has further said.....

"If you reply they will give a rejoinder. You reply again they will issue another rejoinder. It will continue like this and no purpose will be served." 


(
Refrence:Insight into dawah and its understanding & cognition PAGE NO 181)


DARDMANDANA APPEAL MUSALAMANON SE
1.Dunia ki zindagi be sabat hai. Aur yahan kamiyabi ka akela rasta Allah ke hukmon wali zindagi aur Rasulullah sallahu Alaihi wasallam wala rasta hai. Jise deen kahte hain. 

2.Deen zindagi mein mehnat se aata hai. Deen ki mehnat ki ek asaan aur mufeed shakal Allah ne Maulana Ilyas Rahimullah ke zarie dunia mein Aam karayee. Ab ham sab ko apne jaan maal waqt ki qurbani ke satth is kaam ko maut tak karna hai. 

3.Is kaam mein koi shakhsiat parasti nahin hai. Maulana Ilyas Rahmatullah Alaihi (Allh unke qabr ko noor se bhar de) Kaam ke taarruf ke silsile mein bhi apna naam tak lena pasand nahi karte the.

4. Asal deen hai aur uski mehnat hai. Afrad to aate jatee rahenge. Aaj Maulana Ilyas Rahimullah nahi hai Lekin dawat ka kaam hai. Aaj jo akaabir hain sab ek din mar jaenge lekin dawat ka kaam yah chalta rahega Insha Allah.

5.Ham apne tamam maujooda akaabir se milkar rahein. Kisi se kam aur zyada muhabbat fitri cheez hai lekin kisi ko kisi se badguman nahin hona hai.Badgumani bada gunah hai. Isliye tamam akabireen se muhabbat karte hue ham apne aakhirat ki fikr karein

6.Dawat ke kaam mein Ameer koi uhda ya mansab nahin hai. Balki 1 bahut badi zimmedari hai. Ameer khadim hota hai. Yah kaam Ijtamaiat ka hai.Ijtamaiat mein Khair, Allah ki Madad ka Wada aur Fitnon se Hifazat hai. Hamara nizam Hamesha se Ijtamiaat aur ittahade fikr ka raha hai.Ameer banane ya na banane ka faisla shura karegi. Kisi Musalaman ko Ameer banne ki khahish rakhna Allah ki madad ko hata deta hai. Aur beghair mashwara ke kisi ke ameer hone ka elan aur imarat par bait karna bahut badi khiyanat hai. Hazrat Umar Raziallahu Anhu ne ispar sakht baat kahi hai. Yeh bahut bada fitnah hai.

7.Shura mein to chand afraad hote hain who inazamee umoor ke liye Iske alawa haemin aur jitney bhi Ahle Haq Ulma aur akabir hain Chahe who deen ke kisi shobe Tabligh Taleem Tazkiya Tasneef mein hon un sab ki izzat aur muhabbat karni hai. Jo akabir Tabligh ke field mein hain unmein se chand naam yah hain unke alawa jo Shura mein hain.  Maulana Muhammed Ihsan ul Haq sahab ,Maulana Tariq jameel sahab (db) ,Dr Sanaullah sahab (db), Maulana Ismail Godhra sahib, Dr Muhammed Khalid Siddiqui sahib, Bhai Chaudhry Muhammed Rafeeq sahib, Bhai Farooq sahib, Dr Roohullah sahib, Bhai Bakht Muneer sahib, Professor Abdur Rahman sahib, Abdul Aleem sb, Nadir Ali Khan sb, Maulana Ahmad Bahawalpuri sb, Yah bas chand naam hain Iske alawa jitney bhi Ulma karam hai chahe Tabligh mein jate hon na jate hon Hattaki agar (khuda na khasta, kisi confusion/ashkal ki wajah se) Mukhalifat karte hon tab bhi haemin unka ikram karna hai.



7.Hazrat ji Maulana Inamul Hasan Rahimullah ne zamane ke nazakat aur fitnon ko samajhte hue 10 Afrad ki shura muqarrar ki thee. Ismein se 8 afrad Allah ko pyare ho gaye. Ab sirf 2 Bache the to Mashwara se Haji Abdul Wahab sb ne puri dunia ke zimmedaron se mashwara karke Raiwing Ijtema ke mauqe par 16 Nov 2015 ko usmein 11 afrad ko Jod kar takmeel ki hai. Ismein se 5 akaabir Markaz Nizamuddin ki Ijtamaee Shura ke hain, 5 Raiwind ki shura ke aur 3 Kakrael ki shura ke. 
Tamam Musalman Shura ko Taawwun dain Yani Infaradi Rae se bachte hue Shura ke Ijtamaee Mashwara se Yaksu hokar Allah ke liye Jaan Maal Waqt ki Qurbani ke saath Deen ki Mehnat Karein.

Aur Apni Hidayat aur Sare Insaniat ki Hidayat ki fikr karein.

9.Shura ke Akabireen ke Asmae Garamee neeche hain.

1. Hazrat Maulana Muhammed Saad sahib(db) (Nizamuddin)

2. Haji Abdul Wahhab sahab (db) (Raiwind) 

3. Hazrat Maulana Ibrahim Dewla (db) (Nizamuddin) 

4. Hazrat Maulana Yaqoob saharanpuri (db) (Nizamuddin) 

5. Hazrat Maulana Ahmed Laat (db) (Nizamuddin) 

6. Hazrat Maulana Zuhairul Hasan (db) (Nizamuddin) 

7. Hazrat Maulana Nazrur Rahman (Raiwind) 

8. Hazrat Maulana Abdur Rahman (Raiwind) 

9. Hazrat Maulana ubaidullah Khurshid (db) (Raiwind) 

10. Hazrat Maulana Zia ul Haq (db) (Raiwind) 

11. Hazrat Qari Zubair sahab (db) (kakarayel) 

12. Hazrat Maulana Rabeul Haq (Kakarayel) 

13. Bhai Wasif ul Islam (kakarayel) 

Ismein se jo 5 (Panch) afrad Nizamuddin ke hain who aapas ke mashware se Nizamuddin ke umoor anjam denge.
1.Maulana Saad Sb.
2.Maulana Ibrahim Sb.
3.Maulana Ahmad Laat Sb
4.Maulana Yaqoob Sb
5.Maulan Zaheerul Hasan Sb.

Mashware ka Urdu Typing






Maulana Ilyas the Reviver of Tablighi Movement has Remarked.


Maulana Ilyas remarked (Discourse of Maulana Ilyas Page no 25)

 "Our workers must remember well that if their da'wah (invitation) is not accepted and instead they are insulted,abused or baseless allegations are made against them .  
They should not become despondent and frustrated. 


On such an occasion they should remember that this was the sunnat (established way) and heritage of the Arnbiya (alayhiqus salaam), especially that of our Nabi Muhammad (Sallallahu alaihi wa
sallam). Where does everyone get the good fortune of being belittled
and degraded in the path of Allah?


And wherever they are welcomed and honoured, they should appreciate
this and 
when people listen with enthusiasm to their talks it must be
considered a favour from ,Allah and at no time should they be
indifferent to these favours. It should be considered a great favour to
serve and teach these people even if they may be considered to be of the
 lower classes. In the Quran we are reminded of this in the ayat:
He f m e d d turned away, when the blind approached him for
guidance.

At the same time one must keep a check on the deception of one's own
nafs. The nafs should not consider this acceptance as its own
 perfection. This may lead to the fitnah (cormption)_of hero worship.
 Therefore one should always be on one's guard.


MAULANA MAHMUDUL HASAN the Chief Mufti of Darul Uloom Deoband was an active supporters of Tabligh. Once he opined like this.book tabligh jamaat and Maulana Mahmoodul hasan  page no 16.